Q1 2020 portfolio review: holding on tight, Photo by Mitchel Lensink on Unsplash

Q1 2020: Holding On Tight

After a few decades of investing, it’s tempting to think that you’ve seen it all. But the stock market, not to mention the real world, never fails to surprise.

Taking stock

It feels like we’re through the first phase of this crisis right now. Most developed countries are in lockdown and we’re waiting for new cases and deaths to decelerate, level off, and then hopefully decline.

It’s been amazing to see so many people rally round and help others, not to mention the courage of those on the front lines of the NHS and other vital services.

Attention already seems to be shifting to how long the lockdown will continue for and how quickly the restrictions might be lifted. I’m expecting most governments to be overly cautious, although things may speed up if the likes of China and South Korea don’t see cases rise again.

Stock markets have risen a little from the lows set on 23 March and we’re seeing fewer days with major market moves.

But who knows what will happen next? Markets only started falling on February 20 so did we really see the bottom less than five weeks later? This crash has set records left, right, and centre, so maybe it will surprise us on the way up as well.

On the flip side, global markets are just back to the level they were in late 2018, having reached that point for the first time in mid-2017. On that basis, the fall looks a lot less severe.

A bruising three months

Despite a fall of just over 15%, I don’t feel too bad about my portfolio’s performance as most major markets have dropped even more.

The S&P 500 in the US is down some 20% and the UK market has fallen nearly 25%. A decline in the value of the pound against the dollar has meant global markets in sterling terms ‘only’ declined 17%.

UK markets were supposedly cheap at the start of 2020 but that hasn’t stopped them from underperforming yet again. The big weighting towards oil stocks in the FTSE 100 hasn’t helped of course but there have been heavy drops more or less across the board.

Two-thirds of the FTSE 100 has dropped by 20% or more this year. A tenth has dropped by more than 50%!

That said, a few of the early portfolio reviews I’ve read have all recorded losses of less than 10%: hats off to DIY Investor (UK), Fund Hunter, and Maynard Paton.

Here are my numbers:

Portfolio / BenchmarkQ1 2020Since
Jan 2018
My portfolio-15.1%+4.3%
Vanguard FTSE Global All Cap (fund)-17.0%-3.6%
Vanguard LifeStrategy 100 (fund)-18.0%-5.8%
Vanguard UK All-Share Index (fund)-24.8%-19.1%

Given the make-up of my portfolio, I expect it to track global market indices fairly closely while hopefully eking out a few extra percentage points a year. That still seems to be the case, but I’m yet to hit the three-year mark measuring my returns in this way.

Although I have a core of global trusts and funds, I reckon some 25-30% of my portfolio is weighted towards the UK. Therefore, I consider the Vanguard LifeStrategy 100 fund the best benchmark to measure against (it’s essentially a global tracker but with a 24% UK weighting).

I still track my performance against bog-standard global and UK trackers as additional frames of reference though. And I use fund prices rather than actual indices to provide a better comparison against the returns I could get elsewhere.

Performance by holding

As usual, there’s a wide range of performance numbers from my individual holdings:

HoldingQ1 2020
return
HICL Infrastructure-4.0%
Fundsmith Equity-7.9%
Bluefield Solar Income-9.6%
Lindsell Train Global-10.9%
Smithson-10.9%
HG Capital-12.1%
Gresham House Energy Storage-13.6%
RIT Capital Partners-14.6%
Vanguard All-World ETF-15.4%
JPMorgan Global G&I-15.5%
Baronsmead Venture Trust-16.3%
Princess Private Equity-17.9%
Caledonia-22.2%
Murray International-30.6%
Acorn Income-33.5%
BlackRock Smaller Companies-34.6%
Henderson Smaller Companies-36.4%

At the end of 2019, I was preening myself for having just one holding in the red. Now I have a full set!

My three renewable/infrastructure funds have held up pretty well, though, as have the ‘quality’ end of my global funds (Fundsmith, Smithson, and Lindsell Train Global).




All those saying last year that markets were shifting away from growth and back towards value seem to have jumped the gun somewhat.

My private equity trio — HGCapital, Princess, and Baronsmead — have done OK but it will be a while until the new normal, if there is such a thing, gets worked into their net asset values.

What I consider to be my more conservative global funds — RIT, Caledonia, and Murray International — have been somewhat disappointing. RIT has been the best of the bunch, but had an alarming lurch downwards a couple of weeks back.

The Vanguard ETF I have did better than the Vanguard global tracker I measure against. I suspect this might be a timing difference, with its price being taken at 4:30 pm on 31 March and US markets falling a bit later that day.

The three UK smaller company funds I own have all taken an absolute hammering. Both Henderson and BlackRock leapt some 45% in 2019 so those gains plus a little bit more have now been wiped out.

ISA top-ups

I’m planning to put some more cash to work from next week, once the new ISA year is upon us.

My plan is to split my contributions into two and possibly three tranches over a few weeks but I might just do everything at once to avoid obsessing over price movements.

The UK smaller funds and renewable/infrastructure trusts seem the most likely places I will invest. I’m still building up my positions here and I will probably take a scattergun approach over several holdings.

Buying so far

So far this year, I’ve added a little Acorn Income and Bluefield Solar Income (before corona took centre stage) and some Smithson (both before and after).

I haven’t sold any trusts or funds this year and have no plans to do so at the moment.

When this crisis has passed, I will probably take a look at my position weightings and take a view then on whether to shift anything about a bit. I wouldn’t expect to make any major changes, though.

Dicey dividends

One thing I do like to do is to reinvest my dividends and I use this cash to tweak my position sizes and top up anything that seems to have fallen unduly harshly.

But that could be curtailed somewhat for the remainder of 2020, as I’m expecting a few holdings to cut their dividends.

A few stories have referenced futures pricing in dividend cuts of 30% across the UK market, but I can’t find a free online source for this information.

I’d be surprised if my holdings cut that far. My UK smaller company funds would seem the most vulnerable but no trust has announced anything yet, either with regards to future dividends or those already announced but yet to be paid.

Nine of my trusts, so roughly half of my total number of positions, are due to announce dividends in late April or May so the picture should be a lot clearer then.

The wider world of investment trusts

There’s not a lot to report here, as you might imagine.

The average trust discount has gone from 1.4% at the end of 2019 to 8.5% at the end of the first quarter. However, it did spike a lot higher in mid-March.

Gearing levels have risen a bit, due to the underlying value of investments held falling, but only from 7% to 9%, so it looks like absolute borrowing levels have been reduced a little.

The new issues market has completely dried up — no surprise there — with just one IPO taking place. Nippon Active Value joined the market on 21 February, just as prices started to decline, and raised £103m.




As of 20 March, it had only invested 29% of the cash it raised so it has held up better than most. It reckons that it will take about 6 months to fully deploy all its cash.

The AIC has published a list of the longest-serving trust managers and their thoughts on how to invest now, plus an interesting look at the way the investment trust industry has changed over the last two decades.

They have also updated their list of dividend heroes and the next generation with over 10 years of increases. Both these lists could be a little shorter this time next year.

Keep safe

Our kids have been off school for three weeks now and we’ve settled into a fairly regular routine.

There have been some virtual classes to break things up and the food shops seem to be mostly back to normal.

I’d be surprised if there is much of a change at the first UK lockdown review on 13 April. That could be when deaths are peaking so the numbers are going to look even more worrying.

But with every passing day, we’re getting closer to the end of this crisis.


Disclaimer

Please note that I may own some of the investments mentioned above -- you can see my current holdings on my portfolio page. Nothing on this website should be regarded as a buy or sell recommendation as I'm just a random person writing a blog in his spare time and I am not authorised to give financial advice. Always do your own research and seek financial advice if necessary!


Subscribe to IT Investor

Get an email alert every time I publish a new article. Your email address won't be used for anything else.


Spread the word...

4 Replies to “Q1 2020: Holding On Tight”

  1. Murray International. I used to have a sizeable amount in this trust years ago, it was one of only 4 trusts that I owned. Its performance was stellar “back in the day”. I switched out of Investment Trusts some years ago in favour of passive etfs. Its share price as of yesterday (3/4/20) is approximately what it was back in 2010, combination of poor performance and the Corona slump. Im in two minds to buy some for old times sake.

  2. Hi Michael,

    MYI is one I may well top up as well. Although the price is back to 2010 levels, it’s paid 5/6% a year in dividends on that level over the last decade as well. I (still) like the fact it offers something a little bit different in terms of the regions/companies it invests in compared to my other holdings.

    They usually announce the level for the three interim payouts at the AGM, which has been pushed back from 24 April to 27 April, and it’s going to be interesting to see what they say about the dividend’s sustainability.

  3. Your portfolio seems a little light on technology, Healthcare/Biotech, property and a bit more global diversity Asia/Japan, I know this seems like hindsite, but this would balance out your portfolio.

  4. Possibly, although I get exposure to most sectors and regions through the global trusts, funds and ETF I own.

    That said, I was looking to add some tech and biotech last year but never got round to pulling the trigger. Naturally, they have turned out to be the best places to be in 2020!

    I have a reasonable level of non-listed property assets, so I have tended to avoid adding property funds within my portfolio.

    For Asia and Japan, although I get some additional exposure through Murray, RIT, and Lindsell Train Global, I’m a little light but nothing too egregious. But it’s probably the one region I might consider buying a specific trust for.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © 2018-2020 www.itinvestor.co.uk

Disclaimer: This site is for informational purposes only. We make no assertions as to the accuracy, completeness, suitability or validity of anything on this site.
We will not be liable for any errors or omissions or any damages arising from its display or use. Here's our privacy and cookie policy.